We are calling for RMS to be removed from all leadership positions in the FOSS community, including the FSF and GNU, and for the FSF board to resign. Join us. https://rms-open-letter.github.io/
People are complex.
People are different.
People are irreducable.
This letter is manipulative.
It reduces a person to a set of labels and calls for action.
Even worse, it implies that differing opinions alone are a valid cause to intrude into his life and to separate a person from his life's work.
And not only him, but other people as well.
@houkimenator man, I was really excited to see your post. I thought that people were shitting an awful lot on RMS and I really liked the man's mythology. But then I looked into it more, and ended up signing the letter you're critiquing. His "life's work" should have been more inclusive. Maybe not at the beginning but by the end. It sucks to lose a hero, but I'm better than him. I hope you're better than him too.
@houkimenator has got a point.
> He has shown himself to be misogynist, ableist, and transphobic, among other serious accusations of impropriety
You don't use labels to accuse someone. You use actions they have done. Labels can be dismissed as prejudice, slander or character assassination. Actions are far more solid. "Transphobic" -> "has shown / expressed distain for trans people", or "has made jokes that are offensive to trans people". "Mysogynist" -> "has often relegated women to inferior roles" etc.
All of these must reference known instances (or accusations) of such behavior.
If you're angry and are desperate to do something, it's perfectly understandable, but you don't take a stick to a knife fight. If you're going to fight and mean it, then do it right.
Perhaps it was bad form to assume that those reading the letter already had a full understanding of the accusations against RMS, but they were nice enough to link to an article that did outline the specific concerns and accusations. And that article linked to others. This stuff is not difficult to find. It's not that people can't be awkward and make mistakes, it's that RMS has been told multiple times that his actions are problematic and he refuses to change.
The social network of the future: No ads, no corporate surveillance, ethical design, and decentralization! Own your data with Mastodon! This instance, open to everyone, is physically and spiritually centered on Washington Beach in Columbus, OH.